The
Times, Monday, August 30, 2004
A Step Toward Tax Reform
|
|
If New Jersey
ever is to change its tax system, which for decades has
sat like an enormous dead weight on the property owners
and the economy of the state, its best chance is through
a constitutional convention that would bypass the politically
paralyzed State house and place a comprehensive reform plan
directly before the people for their consideration.
A vital first
step down that road was taken last week when Gov. James
E. McGreevey and legislative leaders appointed a 15-member
task force that will recommend the ground rules for a convention
which, with the voters' approval, would be held in 2006.
Their appointees,
by and large, have a working knowledge of the problems that
flow from an unbalanced tax system in which the property
tax finances 42 percent of government, compared to a national
average of 29 percent, and are committed to finding a solution.
They include Mayor Jo-Anne B. Schubert of South Bound Brook,
president of the New Jersey State League of Municipalities;
Mayor Gary Passanante of Somerdale, chairman of the League's
Property Tax Committee; Montclair State University President
Susan Cole, who also is director of the New Jersey State
Chamber of Commerce; Ernest Reock, former director of the
Rutgers University Center for Government Services; Cy Thannikary
of Upper Freehold, chairman of the non-partisan Citizens
for Property Tax Reform; State Sen. John Adler, D-Cherry
Hill, a co-sponsor with former Sen. Bill Schluter of the
original legislation calling for a constitutional convention
; Assembly Majority Leader Joseph Roberts, D-Bellmawr, another
long-time tax convention advocate; and Senate Minority Leader
Leonard Lance, R-Flemington, who wants a convention that
would examine spending as well as tax policies.
The chair and
co-chair, also highly qualified individuals, are Carl Van
Horn, a Rutgers professor and expert on labor issues, and
Michael R. Cole, a lawyer who advised former Gov. Thomas
Kean on property tax issues. Professor Van Horn said the
task force, which must report to the Legislature and Governor
by Dec. 31, will hold a series of hearings and meetings
- open, as they should be, to the public - beginning early
next month.
Before this work
begins, however, we would urge the chairman to carefully
re-read the language of the law creating his panel. When
he was introduced by Gov. McGreevey Friday, Professor Van
Horn had this to say: "The first question the task
force needs to address is should there be a constitutional
convention. I'm open-minded. I don't know if there should
be or not. We've had plenty of instances where the constitution
has been amended without a convention." In fact, the
law creating the task force, signed by Gov. McGreevey July
6, doesn't leave open the "whether" question.
It assigns the panel these duties:
Considering
and developing recommendations regarding the process of
conducting a constitutional convention designed to change
the existing property tax system. Such recommendations shall
include, but not be limited to, the commended method for
the selection of delegates to the convention, the appropriate
scope of the convention's inquiry and the method for consideration
of the convention's recommendations, and shall identify
the specific issues or questions that the convention should
consider as well as the estimated costs of the convention.
As former Sen.
Schluter wrote in a letter to The Times July 9: "In
passing this bill [A-97], the Legislature and governor finally
recognize that the debate over whether to hold a convention
is over." We agree; it now will be the task force's
job to recommend the convention's scope, content, structure
and process. New Jersey's future will be profoundly affected
by how well it does its work.
|
NJLM - A Step Toward Tax Reform
The
Times, Monday, August 30, 2004
A Step Toward Tax Reform
|
|
If New Jersey
ever is to change its tax system, which for decades has
sat like an enormous dead weight on the property owners
and the economy of the state, its best chance is through
a constitutional convention that would bypass the politically
paralyzed State house and place a comprehensive reform plan
directly before the people for their consideration.
A vital first
step down that road was taken last week when Gov. James
E. McGreevey and legislative leaders appointed a 15-member
task force that will recommend the ground rules for a convention
which, with the voters' approval, would be held in 2006.
Their appointees,
by and large, have a working knowledge of the problems that
flow from an unbalanced tax system in which the property
tax finances 42 percent of government, compared to a national
average of 29 percent, and are committed to finding a solution.
They include Mayor Jo-Anne B. Schubert of South Bound Brook,
president of the New Jersey State League of Municipalities;
Mayor Gary Passanante of Somerdale, chairman of the League's
Property Tax Committee; Montclair State University President
Susan Cole, who also is director of the New Jersey State
Chamber of Commerce; Ernest Reock, former director of the
Rutgers University Center for Government Services; Cy Thannikary
of Upper Freehold, chairman of the non-partisan Citizens
for Property Tax Reform; State Sen. John Adler, D-Cherry
Hill, a co-sponsor with former Sen. Bill Schluter of the
original legislation calling for a constitutional convention
; Assembly Majority Leader Joseph Roberts, D-Bellmawr, another
long-time tax convention advocate; and Senate Minority Leader
Leonard Lance, R-Flemington, who wants a convention that
would examine spending as well as tax policies.
The chair and
co-chair, also highly qualified individuals, are Carl Van
Horn, a Rutgers professor and expert on labor issues, and
Michael R. Cole, a lawyer who advised former Gov. Thomas
Kean on property tax issues. Professor Van Horn said the
task force, which must report to the Legislature and Governor
by Dec. 31, will hold a series of hearings and meetings
- open, as they should be, to the public - beginning early
next month.
Before this work
begins, however, we would urge the chairman to carefully
re-read the language of the law creating his panel. When
he was introduced by Gov. McGreevey Friday, Professor Van
Horn had this to say: "The first question the task
force needs to address is should there be a constitutional
convention. I'm open-minded. I don't know if there should
be or not. We've had plenty of instances where the constitution
has been amended without a convention." In fact, the
law creating the task force, signed by Gov. McGreevey July
6, doesn't leave open the "whether" question.
It assigns the panel these duties:
Considering
and developing recommendations regarding the process of
conducting a constitutional convention designed to change
the existing property tax system. Such recommendations shall
include, but not be limited to, the commended method for
the selection of delegates to the convention, the appropriate
scope of the convention's inquiry and the method for consideration
of the convention's recommendations, and shall identify
the specific issues or questions that the convention should
consider as well as the estimated costs of the convention.
As former Sen.
Schluter wrote in a letter to The Times July 9: "In
passing this bill [A-97], the Legislature and governor finally
recognize that the debate over whether to hold a convention
is over." We agree; it now will be the task force's
job to recommend the convention's scope, content, structure
and process. New Jersey's future will be profoundly affected
by how well it does its work.
|

|
|
|